Tileset Reviews On J2O...

[Gargoyle]

I allready posted this as an article on J2O, but still, i have a request;



Stop rating demo levels!!!! When someone posts a tileset, ive noticed that many reviewers rate the demo level instead of the tileset! It is only a demo level! Its only there to give you an example of what you can do with the tileset!



For example:

My tileset was "rated" 5, and i didn't mind that, but when i read the reveiw, this is what it said:



Review by _____(_____) Rating: 5.0



"im not a Hotel Hater Im neutral

but i realy Dont like this lvl

The Design was Quite Bad

its Very Hard too move with jazz through the lvl

try to make it in a other Style

No Download Recommedation from me Sorry,"



See what i mean? the reviewer was rating the level! All he had to do was say that the level is hard to move around in, and that he wont rate the tileset until the demo level is finished, or something like that.



So please! Rate the tileset, and not the demo level!

[$tilettø]

You better Could say this in ur

Author's description

Like Dont Rate the Demo lvl







-Stil

[Aiko]

I always rate the J2O downloads "as a whole" (including stuff like example levels, music, readme file etc.). It's the overall impression that makes me think good or bad of something. In my opinion every tileset needs an example level. If the author wasn't able to make one, the tileset is pretty much worthless.

But of course, when something is posted as a tileset, i focus my reviews on the tileset :-)

[Talec]

If the author wasn't able to make one, the tileset is pretty much worthless.



Not always, it could just be that the author isn't great at level-making...



Err, no offense Gargoyle ^_^o



~Talec LP

[Michael]

Why don't you get those dumb newbies' IPs and nuke them? <strike>I can help.</strike>

[$tilettø]

Eh Dumb Newbies?

Cant you just stop with everyone calling a Newbie



Btw 213.229.72.140/:P

[Michael]

Your not a Newbie, but I, you, him, we, we all can act as newbies but that'd **** many people off.

[Michael]

<small>On , Gargoyle wrote:</small>

I allready posted this as an article on J2O

Then why don't we read on J2O?

[Fquist_old]

Nitro, you may not cuss on this board..

[roseta]

I am better at making tilesets than lvls most of the time.

To most of you.

_____________________________________________

If someone puts a tileset on jazztwenty(excuse me my two key does not work)

Can someone elese use it to make a lvl or is there a rule about that?

_________________________________________-___

I dont rate demo lvls unless they are good, I rate good tilesets http://jazz2.nagcentral.com/forum/images/smiles/icon_smile.gif