Enoph is enoph. Make up your reviews.

[MoonBlazE]

This has annoyid me in several time that people review so lazy just for get their rank up.
Reviewing isen't about rank, but about giving help to the people so they can learn of their mistakes.
At this upload (http://www.jazz2online.com/downloads/moreinfo.php?levelid=1743), hole 6 people reviewed for tell that the file is not found.
The person understood at the first review, and that should be enoph for get people to understand that the file not is found.

Now another thing is people who forgets to tell something in their Author's description.
...Hello? Is there some intellect creatures on this planet?
It's posible edit your upload and add it.
That review is just for make your review count up.

For get it clean, I don't care if you'r Top reviewer or New reviewer.
Derby is new reviewer, and he's one of the best reviewers.
So why do your guys keep wastering space on useless reviews?

Sorry, but I just HAD to tell this.

I know that I'm not to good either, but did I plop a review on that level for tell this?

[$tilettø]

Let them if they think they have to put something in Details They will else they wont as Simple as that and FoR that 404 Who cares if they say that if its Fixed they just edit Review and Viola

it can annoy you but your not an admin so theres nothing you can do about it

and its "Enough" ..

[MoonBlazE]

Blew my grammar Stiletto =P
So why did you even left review number 6? =)))

[$tilettø]

Trying to see if i already got a new Rank


Nah kidding :-P

i also agree you have a point here.

Oh and theres also an "Edit" Function on JCF :p

[Stijn]

Indeed, Stiletto. You could use it to correct your own grammar and spelling errors.

I totally agree to Moonblaze.

[Tik]

I for one severely need 12 people to tell me that a download doesn't work in order for me to believe it.

[Trafton AT]

I agree. I added my review because this was a "cursed account," a strange occurance which makes certain accounts post Not Found files every time.

[Chiyu]

I don't give a * about what my reviewer rank at J2o is.
I just review when I feel like it. Easy :)

[Aiko]

Well, that problem is easy to solve: currently the "j2o rank" is determined by the total number of reviews. I will talk to the responsible persons to determine it by the number of reviews with actual ratings (not including N/A reviews).
By the way, the nice member statistics page makes it very easy to find out which reviewers are good. For example (heh, i didn't say i'm a good reviewer, just as an example :-) check out my ratings.php (http://www.jazz2online.com/downloads/ratings.php?username=Aiko&id=135). Esspecially the average length of the reviews can show you if someone really puts some effort into his or her reviews.

[Disguise]

Whoa, my rating strictness and character length (Rated, not N/A) for reviews are more than Aiko's

That's just scary, but I'll never reach 525 reviews :p

I'm quite nosey what the character length for those reviewers of my tilesets are. You know, the ones that can write a book with the amount they stuck in a review, like Violet, White Rabbit, Flash etc.

It's scary, but I like a good bashing ;)

Oh well, abck to topic, my N/A reviews should be less (my rough guess is that 48.7% of my 'reviews' are N/A), but this value almost matches the amount of uploads I've made, I can't help but comment to bashing, and Aiko can't help to comment to me to keep it lower ;)