I agree with R3ptile. I was on somebody's list! Yay! *cries* But the list seemed to be aimed toward the most active players.. not neccasarilly the best. If I had to come up with a list of the most active all around players, I would say...
1.) Defost **
2.) BeckY **
3.) LAbRaTkiD TF
4.) FireSworD DM
5.) Blacky[Si]
6.) Blur[Si]
7.) RoWodin *
8.) sAlAmAnDeR DM
9.) DizZy DM **
10.) MattW CC **
* - This player is relatively new, which means he or she may or may not stick with the game.
** - This player hasn't been playing a lot lately, but you can count on the return of the player.
Now for me trying to come up with the best players! Yay! Well, let's try to make an organized list here...
BEST AT DEFENSE (STAYING ALIVE)...
1.) JmaN FoR
2.) Blur[Si]
3.) FireSworD DM
4.) Violet CLM (okay, well, he's not very active, but he's active in hotel servers). *
5.) Enigma TF / Unhit TF (I couldn't decide on one of the two)
BEST AT OFFENSE (ROASTING OTHERS)...
1.) DizZy DM
2.) FireSworD DM
3.) SkulL TF
4.) Trafton GpW (he has been known to go psycho in hotel servers =P)
5.) CelL FoR
BEST AT CTF...
1.) FireSworD DM
2.) DizZy DM
3.) JmaN FoR
4.) CelL FoR
5.) EvilMike DM (he's not all that active, but, who cares?)
BEST AT BATTLE...
1.) Violet CLM
2.) FireSworD DM
3.) DizZy DM
BEST IN HOTELS...
1.) JmaN FoR
2.) FireSworD DM
3.) Violet CLM
BEST IN RACES...
1.) Violet CLM
2.) Pyromanus GpW
3.) DizZy DM
BEST IN TEAM EVENTS...
1.) DizZy DM
2.) Unhit TF
3.) CelL FoR

Okay, now it's time to look at the stats...
JmaN FoR - 3
Blur[si] - 1
FireSworD DM - 5
Violet CLM - 4
Enigma TF - 1
SkulL TF - 1
Trafton GpW - 1
CelL FoR - 3
EvilMike DM - 1
DizZy DM - 5
Unhit TF - 2
Pyromanus GpW - 1

So, I suppose I should conclude that the top players are...

1.) A tie between FireSworD DM and DizZy DM
2.) Violet CLM
3.) A tie between JmaN FoR and CelL FoR
4.) Unhit TF

The people who got 1 point aren't neccasarilly worthy of being on the top list as that means they're only in the top tier in one category.

These are just my personal oppinions. If you don't agree with me, too bad. =D