You have to understand that rating standards have changed over time, the review by Trafton you quoted is three years old.

In your review you need to support your opinion. You aren't being asked for two pages, just valid support that explains WHY it is bad or good to you. Writting one line, "this is good", is going to result to be removed.

Also I see no reason to blame Trafton and Violet. They just enforce the rules. They didn't make them.