Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lama
|
J2O did not exist that long ago. It was probably in mid or late 2002; back then, this sort of review was acceptable.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lama
I don't know when you passed the rule that useless reviews will be removed but is that how you repair reviews?
|
A while back, users started to complain that reviews were of poor quality. They were too short, and Newspaz started to remove them. If you mean "you" as in me, I have never passed any new rule that I am aware of. I'm not sure what you mean by this, but I suppose the short answer would be yes. Part of "repairing" the downloads section would include removing ratings that are unexplained - the reviews are left as is.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by JJ Tublear
--No total offense when I say this though--
|
Absolutely none taken.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by JJ Tublear
~I'm glad that Trafton doesn't have power in JCF
|
As am I.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by JJ Tublear
~Trafton reminds me so much of Simon from American Idol, doesn't actually do the job, just gets to rate meaning. Simon doesn't sing or ever has, I think, he just gets to flame or commend the singers....Basically review...
|
This is an odd analogy. What job am I not doing? This example would be true if I never reviewed, but the fact is that I HAVE reviewed - quite a lot - and so has Violet. If you mean creating levels, I no longer upload many, but I do create them when I get a chance. I have used JCS for a long time, and am decent with it. Not that it would matter; a basic understanding of JCS mechanics is really all that is required.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by danyjel
Trafton never did it so often like you, Violet. Just don't delete ratings to save any objectivity... You can say "this is short" but not "this is short so rating removed". It makes J2O your own and not our...
|
I am not sure what you mean here, but if you are saying that the J2O administrators are turning it into our site instead of yours, that's an odd point. It sort of is our site - not as much us base admins, but the "main" admins. We maintain the site, and have control over it. It's to some extent an authoritarian meritocracy.
I am going to share this in the J2O Administrators Forum because you feel so strongly about it. I cannot promise there will be any response, but I will do my best to represent what you are trying to say there.
~ Traft
|