http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=3644

This recent upload got 2 reviews. One by me, and one by Joseph Collins.

While I liked it and gave it an 8.0, the other one gave it 2.2

Now I'm completely confused, as I really don't find it as bad.

When comparing both reviews (mine's slightly shorter, I know) I noticed mine was more about how it sounded in the end, while it seems Joseph Collins did judge more about how much work has been put into making the song.

So, what is right? Should one rate on how the song sounds or how hard it was to make?

(I've never really been into reviewing musics, so I'm not quiet sure)