I don't see why he was asking for it. There is no "logic" with clans. Clans can always be exeptions, they're ran by people. Seriously, just let people do what they want to do without ruining their fun ;| heh.
And no I don't see this post as an insult, just as an argument =P. Also I don't really know what happend with you and Xobim, I just stated what I thought about this entire situation.
But really, clans where everyone thought they'd fail survived for ages. It's just about dedication, and that's not something you can see by looking at 1 post from a guy you never seen before.. There's not really something like logic if it's about this stuff, heh