I'm also not bothered by negreps that are not just silly attacks or ad hominems (and those I don't do anything with). If someone gives a good reason, fine. I prefer feedback when it's specified and concrete, so if there is any, sure. Because then I can improve. It bothers me less than when people (like Dermo or Newspaz) keep posting about unspecified flaws in the administration without explaining themselves to any usable extent, since it allows us no way to improve and just makes sure the boards have a foul mood.

So yeah, I'm fine with a separate thread for specifying problems.