Oh look, a thread about reputation; there's no way this can go wrong!

Would it be possible to implement a rough analogue of J2O's quick review system and have more detailed reasons (read: not "stfu") carry more weight?

ETA: Well, yes, negrepping me with a paragraph of lorem ipsum would certainly get around the fix, but it's more work on your part and it doesn't make the problem worse, so I don't think you win this one.