This can work yes, if people will actually rate the sub-aspects too.

But overall i take back my point in an earlier post where i said i like a competition. I remember why I always liked JCSing and that's why there doesn't necessarily need to be a winner. Of course i entered several JCS tournaments too but that was mainly because there were judges i respected and actually knew what they were doing. And it was a good way to promote your level . and a lot of entries is also still different from head to head battling. I hugely dislike the fact that there can't be judges out of the levelmaking clans, even it makes sense for the bias.