Woohoo! I'm eating the kind of the cake the tileset was based on right now.

Victory speech!
Thanks to Olsen for starting a competition which gave us three new tilesets.
Thanks to Biology, Without which I'd never have gone on that class trip during which I designed a tileset which was never finished but which contributed graphics to CaKeY.
Thanks to Tesco for selling me cake. Gooood cake.
Thanks to the academy.

I don't really think any of the tilesets deserved to win. It's really a matter of taste. And while cake is plenty tasty, the other two sets were aesthetically outstanding. So thanks to Disguise and Unknown. If they hadn't entered I probably wouldn't have made much of an effort.