I support deletion of everything but the Jazz statue, which should be recolored orange and not have a flag attached to it. The rock statue is a nice idea but it would be easier to redraw it than to figure out how to edit it into something which looks plausible.

Originally Posted by Birdie

Delete them all

Originally Posted by Cooba

When voting, clearly specify why do you want to keep/throw out the desired tiles.

Ahem.

This entire problem with alleged power abuse and agreement by silence would be solved if you added a minimum votes requirement before a voting round is valid.

* The EU flag
Delete, I dont think it would be used by anyone (not even by me )

* The Jazz/EU Flag statue
I dont care.

* The rock statues
Keep, the depixelated version looks nice.

* Horizontal waterfalls
Delete, they're not really useful

* Multicolored Inferno trees
Delete, I don't think it fits.

Originally Posted by Birdie

... it still has lines o plenty ;(

If you mean the horizontal lines, thats because its an animation.

EU Flag - like the others said, doesnt fit at all. delete =D
Jazz Statue - doesn't really fit too much and is somewhat ugly. delete.
Rock Statues: too ugly ;( delete.
Horizontal Waterfalls: apparently pointless. delete
Inferno Trees: even more pointless than the waterfalls delete!

(it was my idea to make cooba delete all of this on the 28th, btw. i'm evil )

hey guys i have an idea lets delete the whole tileset its ugly

Originally Posted by R3p

hey guys i have an idea lets delete the whole tileset its ugly

I agree Now stop fooling around.

Votes thus far (latest vote tallied belongs to P4ul):

EU Flag: 9 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Jazz Statue: 7 Delete, 1 Keep (88%)
Rock Statues: 7 Delete, 2 Keep (78%)
Horizontal Waterfalls: 9 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Inferno Trees: 9 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)

Originally Posted by Odin

EU Flag: 9 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Jazz Statue: 7 Delete, 1 Keep (88%)
Rock Statues: 7 Delete, 2 Keep (78%)
Horizontal Waterfalls: 9 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Inferno Trees: 9 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)

Birdie's and Dx's votes didn't count, by the way. That makes it:

EU Flag: 7 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Jazz Statue: 5 Delete, 1 Keep (88%)
Rock Statues: 5 Delete, 2 Keep (78%)
Horizontal Waterfalls: 7 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Inferno Trees: 7 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)

I think we could use one last week-long extension to the deadline. I don't think the LMAT should end with a vote for deletion, plus I want enough time to finish my tiles without having to rush (I'm also busy with classwork at the moment).

I was just considering another deadline extension, too. Have another additional week of tiles, then.

Originally Posted by Cooba

Birdie's and Dx's votes didn't count, by the way.

Oh, alright, lemme adjust the percentages.

EU Flag: 7 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Jazz Statue: 5 Delete, 1 Keep (83%)
Rock Statues: 5 Delete, 2 Keep (71%)
Horizontal Waterfalls: 7 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Inferno Trees: 7 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)

My votes!

EU Flag: Pointless = delete.
Jazz Statue: Just change its pose and improve it a bit in colors and then keep, if not, delete.
Rock statues: Not pixelated version is good, keep and add a yellow/brown version.
Horizontal Waterfalls: They're a nice water surface (just make it a little less water-like and with better colors (aka redesigned) and then keep, if not, delete.
Inferno Trees: I don't really know if they fit, so no vote here.

Originally Posted by Pako Spanrabbit

My votes!

EU Flag: Pointless = delete.
Jazz Statue: Just change its pose and improve it a bit in colors and then keep, if not, delete.
Rock statues: Not pixelated version is good, keep and add a yellow/brown version.
Horizontal Waterfalls: They're a nice water surface (just make it a little less water-like and with better colors (aka redesigned) and then keep, if not, delete.
Inferno Trees: I don't really know if they fit, so no vote here.

uh, did you add something? I'm not sure if you did.

Originally Posted by Agent Cooba

For two days from now, everyone who has successfully contributed to the tileset may vote for or against removal of the following tiles:

Hahaha, ++Odin. I almost forgot 'Agent Cooba' existed.

if I was able to vote, I would agree with all exept for the rock statues. Little improvements and they are a nice eye candy:P

EDIT: oh yea, ++ --Cooba for being acting like 'Agent Cooba'

Originally Posted by Jerrythabest

EDIT: oh yea, ++ --Cooba for being acting like 'Agent Cooba'

for abusing a rule leak*. 'Agent Cooba' has nothing to do with this .

oh sorry then XD

on a side note: let's remake the LMAT idea!

LMAT Spring (Dec-Feb)
LMAT Summer (Mar-May)
LMAT Autumn (Jun-Aug)
LMAT Winter (Sep-Nov)

So when it's spring 2006 theres LMAT Summer 2006 you get it?
3 months to make a season-themed LMAT...:P Ill make a thread about this on the 31st of May... for the LMAT Autumn 2006 version:P sounds great, let's see if we have to expand the deadline again then too! *sits here waiting till 31st May 11:59 PM to post*

Originally Posted by Jerrythabest

oh sorry then XD

on a side note: let's remake the LMAT idea!

LMAT Spring (Dec-Feb)
LMAT Summer (Mar-May)
LMAT Autumn (Jun-Aug)
LMAT Winter (Sep-Nov)

So when it's spring 2006 theres LMAT Summer 2006 you get it?
3 months to make a season-themed LMAT...:P Ill make a thread about this on the 31st of May... for the LMAT Autumn 2006 version:P sounds great, let's see if we have to expand the deadline again then too! *sits here waiting till 31st May 11:59 PM to post*

Although I DO like the idea of a 3 month LMAT, they don't have to be season themed. Anyway, more time is also welcome. ;P

Let's talk about ADDING stuff instead of DELETING them now, shall we? I'll make some spikes for the normal soil this afternoon.

I think 2 months should suffice...

How about "LWOAT", where we Work On a tileset but never finish it?

Originally Posted by Radium

How about "LWOAT", where we Work On a tileset but never finish it?

Ok, you can shut up now. :P

or LMATATEATIT (=lets make a tileset and then erase all tiles in it)

Okay, I got enough of you people deleting everything.




I made some spikes and a 'pling' animation. Faw did a reshade on my vines.

Imposing a time limit of 1 month is needlessly ambitious. If we succeed, we'll be able to look back, point at the tileset, and say 'we made that in 1 month'. But really, why rush? I remember a Liberty freight ship destined for Atlantic convoy duty being built in just 1 week, as part of American industrial propaganda during WWII...well, truth is, some Liberty ships tended to break apart in half in stormy weather. Why don't we just make 2 months the default time limit so there isn't an unpredictability over extensions...(and if you go pass a 2 month deadline, you can blame me ).

Almost over, kids! Vote now.

EU flag - Still no European tiles cropping up...delete.
Emerald statue with EU flag - I've always disliked the huge bulging eye. ;p Delete.
Rock statues which don't look like statues - Delete. They have bad texturing and don’t even look like statues.
H. waterfalls - keep these...if we're deleting the horizontal waterfall, why are we keeping their vertical counterparts? They don't stick out like the other tiles and who knows what they could be used for?
Inferno trees - delete, they belong in Inferno.

EDIT: We're not voting against the gargoyles? So which gargoyle are we using? The green or yellow ones?

Originally Posted by White Rabbit

Gargoyle - delete, they belong in Medivo.

Uh no. We're voting against the rock statues added in this post and not the gargoyles. Fix vote plz

Votes thus far (last vote tallied belongs to White Rabbit):

EU Flag: 8 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Jazz Statue: 6 Delete, 1 Keep (86%)
Rock Statues: 6 Delete, 2 Keep (75%)
Horizontal Waterfalls: 7 Delete, 1 Keep (88%)
Inferno Trees: 8 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)

And now, with the period of 48 hours over, the vote is now closed.

The results (thanks to Odin)

EU Flag: 8 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)
Jazz Statue: 6 Delete, 1 Keep (86%)
Rock Statues: 6 Delete, 2 Keep (75%)
Horizontal Waterfalls: 7 Delete, 1 Keep (88%)
Inferno Trees: 8 Delete, 0 Keep (100%)

All of the voted tiles are now considered as deleted. Thanks for your cooperation

I like how the rock statues, which were mainly considered the main issue in the arguement two or so pages back were just on the brink of being kept.

And you're welcome.

Originally Posted by Jerrythabest

or LMATATEATIT (=lets make a tileset and then erase all tiles in it)

Haha, yeah. I vote for this name.

thanx XD

Originally Posted by Radium

Haha, yeah. I vote for this name.

Well, I vote for it too.
That's 3 votes! By default, Cooba votes against, keeping the name LMAT.

The results:
LMATATEATIT: 3 for, 1 against. (75%)
LMAT: 1 for, 3 against. (25%)

75% majority on LMATATEATIT! Voting closed.

(WA)



[Wide attack removal. You get a subwarning for the combination of this offense with several other recent ones. - FQuist]

hmm I will make one at the 31st of may anyways, no matter what's the project's name

Originally Posted by CrimiClown®

Well, I vote for it too.
That's 3 votes! By default, Cooba votes against, keeping the name LMAT.

The results:
LMATATEATIT: 3 for, 1 against. (75%)
LMAT: 1 for, 3 against. (25%)

75% majority on LMATATEATIT! Voting closed.

Originally Posted by Cooba

(WA)

I like this thread.

...nice job on the tileset, anyway.

[Previous quotation edit - FQuist]

that was sarcasm eh? at LEAST the 'like this thread' part:P

Originally Posted by Jerrythabest

that was sarcasm eh? at LEAST the 'like this thread' part:P

Not really, this thread is awesome. Fights > Stuff.

...yes!