Review by Skitter

Posted:
4 Jan 2011, 15:35
For: Hotel by Xander
Level rating: N/A
Rating
N/A

Man , super hotel
Why you don’t join my server?

Not recommendedReview by StarLORD

Posted:
23 Jul 2010, 12:46 (edited 3 Aug 10, 13:12)
For: Sirpentus Rhinno
Level rating: 5.6
Rating
5
Us cannot understand why xander made levels with annoying bugs and idk why he don’t know how to fix them.This is horrible in discovering and get stuck in a tileset which is this: xlmbeach. So i don’t give recommandation because this level really suffers crashes and tile-bugs which i hate them. That’s it .I don’t recommend this.

~StarLORD

Not recommendedQuick Review by Seren

Posted:
9 Jul 2010, 15:34 (edited 9 Jul 10, 15:36 by Sir Ementaler)
For: Sirpentus Rhinno
Level rating: 5.6
Rating
5.5

Oh well, I must agree it’s more than I ever expected from a 256×64 level which takes only about 1/3 of this space. But that’s surely not enough for me to call it a good one. The eyecandy is nothing special, as well as the gameplay and the pickup placement. Everything is just average. Much too short and easy to get a DR.

RecommendedQuick Review by YRSHKD

Posted:
9 Jul 2010, 10:25
For: Sirpentus Rhinno
Level rating: 5.6
Rating
7

A lot of warps, some tile bugs.
But i liked this level because a lot of eyecandy and good gameplay.

RecommendedQuick Review by StarLORD

Posted:
25 Jun 2010, 11:03
For: Stay in Space.j2l
Level rating: 6.2
Rating
6.5

nice level. i liked triggers
and eyecandy

RecommendedReview by StarLORD

Posted:
18 Jun 2010, 19:27 (edited 4 Aug 10, 16:12)
For: Syetyan Park
Level rating: 1.6
Rating
1

I just tested this level and results:

EYECANDY-very borring and he can be repeated at every point.So i think you must made levels with other tilesets.
This is an a tileset for BIG LEVELS.
But also you made next level called

GAMEPLAY-mmm very borring.I did discovered a lots of carrots and enemies.Enemies are in not same number with carrots. The carrots are 2 per 1 way.This is not good for who wanna to make an a great SP pack.I think you’ll made more good GAMEPLAY in future. Weapon / AMMO placement-mm there are some seekers,RF and something did you put.I don’t discovered any Warp secret. And any Coins.Why did you not made a secret warp with coins? this made the gameplay borring. Because this,I’ll give you a penalty. Pickups-hmm there are any PU and i don’t have comment do to in this CATEGORY. BUGS-yay a lots of tile-bugs i did founded.I was stuck at level’s start at those events on a BALOON.Hmph if you wanna to make a new version of Syetyan Park,this will be good. Or better: reupload this and fix all and drag them to readme and here, at upload info. IMPORTANT SUGGESTIONS: don’t put Save Point at end of level because this is also very unfortunatly and then just make a normal number of carrots and not a lots. Screenshots: Here is the Save Point at the end of level: And those 2 carrots per 1 way:

I’ll hope you’ll make better levels in
FUTURE.
Final rating is 4.5.
Recommended? No

If you want to see other uploads,click on this:
Sirpentus Rhinno .

Adding music made me to increase rating

~This review has been edited by StarLORD.

Review by Xander[NB]

Posted:
17 Jun 2010, 09:15 (edited 3 Jul 10, 07:23)
For: Syetyan Park
Level rating: 1.6
Rating
N/A

It have a music!
And isn’t first upload!

Not recommendedQuick Review by PurpleJazz

Posted:
13 Jun 2010, 14:35 (edited 10 Dec 10, 19:43)
For: Syetyan Park
Level rating: 1.6
Rating
2

This level suffers from one fatal flaw: there’s way too many carrots. Seriously, there’s at least one carrot every 6 or so tiles you move, meaning that it is practically impossible to die here, even on Hard. Aside from that, there’s not really much to say, aside from the bland eyecandy and overly linear level design. E+

Quick Review by cool spaz

Posted:
1 Apr 2010, 01:45
For: My First LVL
Level rating: 1.8
Rating
2

this level is good considering that its a first but in the next time you make an other level try to put more eye candy,pick ups and don’t have places that you can fall

Quick Review by Veleo Vampir

Posted:
22 Mar 2010, 11:58 (edited 22 Mar 10, 12:03 by Stijn)
For: Sea Storm
Level rating: 4
Rating
N/A

Nice but contains bugs.

Fix bugs

[Duplicate account of BlackXander. ~Stijn (Original rating 9.7)]

Quick Review by draykon

Posted:
18 Mar 2010, 14:31 (edited 18 Mar 10, 14:36 by Stijn)
For: SP Pack
Level rating: N/A
Rating
N/A

Great levels. I’ll download them right now!

[You’re doing it wrong; first download and play the levels, THEN review. ~Stijn (Original rating 10.0)]

Review by alex_hr2000

Posted:
17 Mar 2010, 15:40
For: Sea Storm
Level rating: 4
Rating
N/A

Good Level!

Not recommendedQuick Review by KiMO

Posted:
16 Mar 2010, 07:56
For: Sea Storm
Level rating: 4
Rating
4

A little bigger than the last one, but still bugged and not so many pointless things, like start positions for example.

Review by YRSHKD

Posted:
11 Mar 2010, 09:23
For: My First LVL
Level rating: 1.8
Rating
N/A

It’s bad but It’s your first lvl, so it can be bad :)
My first lvl was bad too :)
Let’s make some lvl :)
(Sorry my bad english, I’m turkish.)

Review by Steven(HsC)

Posted:
7 Mar 2010, 17:34
For: Hotel by Xander
Level rating: N/A
Rating
N/A

cool

Review by minmay

Posted:
5 Mar 2010, 14:21
For: My First LVL
Level rating: 1.8
Rating
N/A

A note about PT32’s point on music: using any format not supported by JJ2’s Galaxy Music System will crash non-Plus users, old-Plus users, and Plus users who use the Plus injector instead of the Plusifier.

Also, make sure the music in question is legal to use in your level. And that it hasn’t already been used in a bunch of other levels. (I recommend searching modarchive.org.)

Not recommendedQuick Review by KiMO

Posted:
5 Mar 2010, 12:35
For: My First LVL
Level rating: 1.8
Rating
1.2

Your intentions maybe were to make a ‘‘first level for someone’‘, but you can do it using a better tile-set. Anyway, don’t download this. :D

Not recommendedReview by PT32

Posted:
4 Mar 2010, 17:32 (edited 12 Mar 10, 22:41)
For: My First LVL
Level rating: 1.8
Rating
2

I am going to hurry up and give you a helpful review before everybody jumps on the bandwagon and criticizes you for this. Which I’m afraid, they will.

First off, I’m giving you one point because this is your first level (As you said), and I usually give first levels a +1 point. But there are some serious flaws. Your level construction is almost okay, but I could find nothing preventing me from simply finding a high spot and helicoptring to the end. That’s poor design there. There’s no eyecandy. No music. Not even a name! There were some events, but these were very poorly placed. The tileset was also very underrused. The level, overall, looked massively unfinished.

I can help with some of this. First of all, fill in all the gaps. Unlike in some games, the edge of the JJ2 maps is not a death pit, you will simply float there and frustrate yourself in playing. Fill in the holes.

Next, deal with eventage. Most if not all the enemies are in small holes guarding events. What ones aren’t (and these are predominately aerial baddies) are strewn either randomnly or in clumps. Take a cue from EvilMike’s singleplayer beauties. Or some of Agama’s wondrous levels. There’s lots of good examples out there, and you will learn a lot from ‘em. Food and misc. is also clumped, somewhat few and a wee bit far between. Some ubercheap powerups [a.k.a. PU’s] like the seekers are placed right in plain sight, not providing much of a challenge to obtain. There’s plenty you can do to fix it.

Add a good song. Music is literally a little less than half the importance of any good pack. If you use a circus song on a spooky level, that won’t work. If you use a sad song on say, Discoland, that doesn’t do it either. And let’s not even go into disco music’s do’s and don’ts. I would recommend some kinda fast medieval songs for your level, or even just the plain Medivo song (Which if you have JJ2, just go to level properties and type “Medivo”. A tip: Any non-j2b format song will require you to add a file extension on the end. Some good ext’s include MOD, XM, S3M, IT, or even MP3 and WAV, what with the new JJ2+ progs)

A level name is good too, but I won’t launch into a long spiel about what to name it. You should be able to come up with something.

Next, and perhaps most importantly, add some good eyecandy eyecandy period, to your level! Ask anyone on J2O. You won’t find a single person who won’t say you need good eyecandy to make a good level. Do you know that there are 3 foreground layers and 4 background layers in the JCS? There are, so use them! Put a gargoyle in here and there. A column of rock in the foreground (though be careful how you place baddies around these). A flag rippling in the breeze. The unmasked rock bg. There’s any number of good and perfectly fine things to be done with eyecandy, so make sure you do at least some of them. And layer 8? If you look in the editor, you should see that there’s a background image for the level that’s 8×8 tiles. If you click “textured bg” in the layer 8 properties, you can make your bg twice as good. And certainly better than the one you have now.

I don’t think I need mention buggage. Always, always, ALWAYS go over and check your levelsfor bugs. I can’t stress that enough, as so many people (myself included) have fallen hard for not making sure they had a clean level. Make sure the masks are all good. That you can’t get stuck in any spots. That events and enemies aren’t placed so’s that they’ll kill you as soon as you get there. Check, check, and check again. Okay, I DID kinda mention it, but it is that important.

Finally, gameplay. Your level, I’m sad to say, didn’t have a whole lotta it. It was mostly back-and-forth-go-down-and-end. Add some warps to spice it up. Use trigger scenery (That’s a whole nother discussion—read the wiki entry here or ask one of the older sages of J2O to learn more.). Add some variety in the level, but don’t make it too long or too short. Eventually, you’ll find the right balance. Get some friends to test stuff out for you, to make sure you won’t make a colossal flop out of your dream project.

So, what can I say? This turned out quite a bit longer than I had intended, but I think that’s good. You’ll hopefully learn something from this, or I haven’t done my job. I’m so glad you put your stuff up here, but make sure it’s only your best efforts you add. Many many site members take a dim view to half-baked stuff, so do your best and don’t just churn levels out like a conveyor belt. You’ll get it eventually. I know you will.
2.0, but no dl rec. You just need a little more time. Hang in there, you’ll get your chance soon enough!

Keep Jazzing!
PT32

EDIT: I have this nagging feeling that I wrote this review kinda treating you like a newbie. My profuse apologies if you saw it that way too. :(

Note to Minmay: I heartily agree.

Review by YRSHKD

Posted:
28 Feb 2010, 18:29
For: JJ1 Pack
Level rating: N/A
Rating
N/A

That’s good, but there are better Candion tileset than it.
(Sorry my english, I’m Turkish)

Review by Jahari

Posted:
26 Feb 2010, 20:18
For: Et's Planet:Green Caves
Level rating: N/A
Rating
N/A

For bugfixes:

- Make sure the walls tile all the way to the ceiling in the top right area.

- Make sure the level ends with “End” in the next level string.

The eyecandy of this level is good, but not amazing. This particular tileset makes it easy to pretty things up. I’d be curious to see how you make use of a more simple tileset. The waterfalls in the foreground were repetitive and made it hard to see. If you really want to use that many, don’t spread them all over the foreground like seagull poo on a windshield.

Gameplay was okay in the sense that it was consistent in the level (no contrast between unique ideas and boring parts). There was nothing new or particularly challenging. It was also short.

You can probably recycle this level into something better, but I’d give it a 5 for effort.

  1. 1
  2. 2