Not recommendedQuick Review by cooba

Posted:
22 Feb 2009, 19:21
For: Cold Rush
Level rating: 1.0
Rating
1.0

unsuccessful troll is unsuccessful

Review by cooba

Posted:
8 Feb 2009, 12:10 (edited 17 Jan 12, 01:25)
For: Enter the Chaos
Level rating: 8.2
Rating
N/A

[23:25] <@BlurredD> Interesting fact: part of my fix for preventing the flag bug which caused “[player] captured the flag” spam messages apparently created a side effect where smoke rings can to wrap around a level and rise from the bottom. Oops.

Review by cooba

Posted:
1 Feb 2009, 12:32
For: Journey through the Carrotus
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
6.5

(I ran this pack under TSF to overcome the animations error)

This is a pretty standard JJ2 romp, with several details making it stand out from the rest. The first level greets you with a variety of available paths which must be taken before advancing further. This, combined with the amount of goodies found everywhere, encourages exploration, which is an important aspect in most of these levels—the earlier ones at least.

The levels are also pretty standard on the visual side. There’s no overly revolutionary tile work, though using custom tileset edits made a few levels feel fresh (I liked the background in the first level a lot). The use of JJ3 music also helped, though some of the track choices were questionable (Basement Boss in a dimly lit swamp?).

One thing I noticed is that the overall level quality seemed to go down as I progressed through the pack. The first level felt cool and well polished, where as the final level was a big letdown. It uses a stock tileset, the music barely matches, is very linear, has a number of unfair challenges (namely the bird morph sequence), uses instakill without any forewarning, and has no endboss?? Combine this with several bugs in the previous levels, namely the Rocket Turtle who completely failed to work for me, and you have a buggy, unpolished SP pack.

Conclusions? An above average pack that starts out promising and goes steadily downhill, yet not to the rock bottom. Download if you’re bored, or if you want to look at the pretty first level =P

Review by cooba

Posted:
13 Jan 2009, 12:52 (edited 14 Jan 09, 21:54)
For: Regicide Road
Level rating: 8.6
Rating
N/A

It’s still not entirely fixed because the leaders score two points with Capture Wait disabled, and one with enabled.

EDIT: I’ll bite you.

RecommendedQuick Review by cooba

Posted:
26 Dec 2008, 19:13
For: Hero 4 Hire - The Final Adventures
Level rating: 8.7
Rating
8.8

This episode is brilliant, definitely an example of thinking out of the box if compared to other levels from the same time. What’s kinda creepy is that these were made at the same time I’d made my very first levels. Cool huh? Download now.

Review by cooba

Posted:
13 Dec 2008, 16:52
For: Winter Dreams: 1.23
Level rating: N/A
Rating
N/A

And you included the TSF versions of the levels why..?

Quick Review by cooba

Posted:
2 Dec 2008, 13:03 (edited 14 Sep 13, 18:13)
For: Codename: Alliance
Level rating: 8.4
Rating
7.0

What Cell said.

RecommendedQuick Review by cooba

Posted:
11 Nov 2008, 11:51
For: How A Video Game Saved the World
Level rating: 6.8
Rating
7.0

This man thinks outside the box.

Review by cooba

Posted:
4 Nov 2008, 20:38 (edited 4 Nov 08, 20:39)
For: New Diamondus
Level rating: 7.1
Rating
N/A

FawFul: There’s nothing absurd about Stijn’s review. He’s entitled to have an opinion about your work, and to defend it. Just as you are entitled to disagree with his rating and his arguments. However, you’re overreacting. I don’t see how did you infer hostility from Stijn’s review – your comments about personal attacks and distrust are out of place here.

Master Sven: Please don’t jump into the gray area of public debate.

Certain people: Please do remember that downrating a review just because you disagree with the rating is wrong. Like Stijn said, read the review first, and think about what you’re doing. Grytolle, who took time to read through Stijn’s review (even if he still downvoted), is a good example.

I want this mess to cease, starting now. I don’t want to see this kind of situation to happen again, so please let us cooperate.

Review by cooba

Posted:
21 Jul 2008, 16:30 (edited 28 Jul 08, 12:44)
For: Sultans GunPalace
Level rating: 7.9
Rating
7.1

9 is extreme overrating.

The eyecandy is a mess. This level attacks you with a multitude of colors basically everywhere, with the ambient lighting making it even more chaotic. The amount of decoration in every place feels almost forced to some point, there’s just too much at too many places. While this is apparently a palace, every piece of the layout is random and unordered as if it was a nature level all over.

Speaking of an unordered layout.. this level is almost like a battle level with bases. It would take a while to learn some basic routes and tactics here, let alone master them.. This level may be sure challenging, but it’s on the end of the spectrum where annoying levels go. I’m not sure if anyone would consider playing here.

Overall, a lot of effort went into this level, but in some places it went into details that shouldn’t have been there. Keep making levels, but make them less messy, please.

(PS. The text strings were very bothersome, by the way.)

EDIT: I didn’t mean to say this level is completely bad. It’s obvious that a lot of effort went into it, shows the months gone into JCS’ing. It’s just that the level is more to look at rather than play, which is not too good. Overall, I’m giving this a 7.1 not because it’s bad, but because it’s not very good yet.

Quick Review by cooba

Posted:
21 Jul 2008, 13:19 (edited 21 Jul 08, 13:20)
For: Troglobite's Dark Forest Adventure
Level rating: 7.5
Rating
6.4

This really isn’t what PT32 says, but it’s not exactly a very good pack either. The tileset is a start, and it’s good to see people make tilesets specifically for their packs. The design got repetitive after a while, though it did have its moments (I liked the spike boll maze). Overall, this pack is a good start, and I hope to see more.

Review by cooba

Posted:
21 Jul 2008, 13:14
For: Jazz Graphics Pack
Level rating: 8.0
Rating
N/A

An awesome lot of work there :D Thanks a lot DD.

Not recommendedReview by cooba

Posted:
1 Jul 2008, 20:00 (edited 1 Jul 08, 20:03)
For: jp-->3-1 Fanolint
Level rating: 3.1
Rating
1.0

If I wanted to play a JJ1 level, I’d go play JJ1 instead of downloading a “Jackpack”, spending an hour trying to figure out what the hell is it and what am I supposed to do with it, only to find out I have to look for the tileset myself in order to play a carbon copy of a JJ1 level. Most of people here have played JJ1 at some point or another, they’ve seen how do the enemies look like, and they’ve heard the Fanolint theme themselves, so tell me: what is the point of this?

Not recommendedReview by cooba

Posted:
29 May 2008, 22:53 (edited 29 May 08, 22:55)
For: Textured backgrounds
Level rating: 5.5
Rating
2.0

Those are THE laziest attempts at textured backgrounds I’ve ever witnessed. These, as noticeable on the first sight at the screenshots, are not much more than a hue change of the background texture used in most of JJ2 official tilesets. Lark is justified, though, because this thing is almost exactly 5 years old as I’m writing this. However, this getting a rating of 9 is something I wouldn’t make up on the most hardcore acid trip.

RecommendedQuick Review by cooba

Posted:
25 Apr 2008, 13:29
For: Submerged Caverns
Level rating: 7.8
Rating
7.3

Good level? Definitely. 8.5? Not really.

Review by cooba

Posted:
23 Apr 2008, 22:16 (edited 23 Apr 08, 22:17)
For: Emerald Forest CTF
Level rating: 7.5
Rating
N/A

“Those of you who think the music does not fit” are usually right and you should listen to people’s advice rather than point them the door out.

Not recommendedQuick Review by cooba

Posted:
16 Apr 2008, 11:21 (edited 17 Apr 08, 18:13)
For: Rumble In The Bogs
Level rating: 7.6
Rating
4.0

The pits ruin it. Download if you want a level to look at.

Review by cooba

Posted:
14 Apr 2008, 16:33 (edited 14 Apr 08, 16:33)
For: Bosses You Haven't seen
Level rating: 5.0
Rating
N/A

For your information: these bosses not exactly new as they’re just respectively old Devan, Bolly, and Uterus with misplaced (uncached) sprites. If you were to put a Devan in the first level, your “Hyper Jazz” would become a Devan. Etc.

Not recommendedReview by cooba

Posted:
25 Mar 2008, 14:58 (edited 1 Apr 08, 13:54)
For: Bosses
Level rating: 1.7
Rating
3.5

This pack was predictable like no other. In half of the total 8 boss combats, Tuf Bosses are put out of player’s reach to back up the otherwise weak boss. That way of making a boss harder is older than I remember, probably dating back to Violet’s TTJJ2 pack (precisely, its final level). Old or not, it’s okay if done right, but six Tuf Bosses at once in the first level definitely isn’t right.

Tuf Bosses aside, these levels are filled with other hazards, mostly spikes and respawning enemies (more annoying cliches), spike balls and smoke rings to a lesser extent. None of those are affected by difficulty settings for some reason or another, which is unacceptable.

Some (unfortunately, not all) of the levels seem to have the general idea behind, which is hindered by the lacking execution. The penultimate level (which I like the most because it doesn’t have Tuf Bosses) becomes the easiest once you figure it out – which is a shame.

There’s not much else that can be said about this. I did not mention the visual aspects because this pack is apparently devoid of those. These levels are repetitive, frustrating, and don’t seem to have taken more than 5 minutes to make, each. If you say that 5 minutes is too less, then ask yourself if these levels were at all tested.

Review by cooba

Posted:
24 Dec 2007, 13:30 (edited 24 Dec 07, 13:30 by Cooba)
For: Winter Wonderland (renamed from A White Christmas)
Level rating: N/A
Rating
N/A

Your name has been taken already again.

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5