Review by Ischa

Posted:
17 Jun 2006, 12:49 (edited 19 Jun 06, 17:41 by Fquist)
For: Ilu'z Jazz X2: Flash from the past
Level rating: 7.3
Rating
N/A

Rating Ilu’z Jazz X2: Flash from the past

Plus:
Level 2 is new.

Minus:
The levels are short. The boss-area’s were too hard and in the fifth level Bubba jumps out of the game. There are also levels ripped from Jazz X1 and the episode has a bad ending.

Conclusion:
While your first episode was OK, this one is an international disaster. If there is a sequel from ‘Ilu’z Jazz X2: Flash from the past’ is I’ll change the rating. But as long there is no sequel, this episode is no download recommendation.

Final Rating: 2,0
Download recommendation: NO!

[Unsupported rating (2.0) removal. You really cannot go around giving levels low ratings because they were used in other packs too. You need to rate the quality of the levels, not wether they were published before. – FQuist]

Review by Ischa

Posted:
17 Jun 2006, 09:51 (edited 17 Jun 06, 09:52)
For: Ilu'z Jazz X: the Future incident
Level rating: 7.7
Rating
6

Rating Jazz X: the Future incident

Good:
A good episode. With a good number of bonusses and secrets the bonus-placement is super. Also a good eyecandy. This episode is also very long: 22 levels!

Not good:
Bosses are only in the first levels, in the rest of the game are no bosses at all. The story is also not clear and some levels are very easy.

Conclusion:
Ilu’z Jazz X: the Future incident is a good episode. But there were some things that could be better.

Final Rating: 6,0
Download recommendation: N/A (requires a 7½)

Review by Ischa

Posted:
17 Jun 2006, 09:42 (edited 19 Jun 06, 15:05 by Fquist)
For: White Manse (Castle Remix)
Level rating: 6.9
Rating
N/A

White Manse:

Rating:
It is a good tune. White Manse is another Castle Remix. It is very clear that this tune is a remix from the classic JJ2-castle-tune.

But there are also problems with this tune: The lead sample is too quiet, too inexpressive… and not very medival…

Conclusion:
It is a fair Castle Remix, but not enough for a sufficient.

Rating: 4,8
Download recommendation: NO!

[Unsupported rating (4.8). It is not made clear why this deserves a low rating, besides one comment about the sample. I was convinced that this was indeed unsupported. (No, the trolling didn’t do that.) – FQuist]

RecommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
11 Jun 2006, 18:44 (edited 11 Jun 06, 18:46)
For: The Godaiku Pack
Level rating: 9
Rating
9.3

Rating The Godaiku Pack

Rating:
Well done! You’ve created a level-pack that IS difficult, but without hurting obstacles. The only obstacle is: finding all objects and go to the exit.
That is very original.

This pack contains 12 levels. That is great. Also that is not good, but extremely great.

The eyecandy is good: there is a nice background and you have created beautiful paths with all the tileset.

The only bad point is: no endboss.

Conclusion:
It is a good, long pack. You can’t die in this episode, but it is still hard.
There are almost no bad points.

Mark: 9,3
Download recommendation: YES!

Review by Ischa

Posted:
11 Jun 2006, 18:35
For: Godaikoku Part 1
Level rating: 8.3
Rating
N/A

I’ve wrote my real rating in The Godaiku Pack, because that is the complete episode.

Review by Ischa

Posted:
10 Jun 2006, 16:52 (edited 13 Jun 06, 18:19 by Violet CLM)
For: Crypt
Level rating: 8.4
Rating
N/A

Rating Crypt:

Rating:
Not the best tileset I’ve ever seen. It is almost 100% brown and pretty hard to use.

The example-level is also bad. Good example levels are small Single Player-levels with enemies. On that way I can see how I must use the tileset.

But the orginality is not bad. I have never seen a JJ2-tileset into a crypt.

Conclusion:
Despite the orginality this tileset is still one of the worst I’ve ever seen. Too brown, too inpractical and no good example-level.
So, I can’t give you any higher than a 1. Sorry.

Mark: 1,0
Download recommendation: NO!
(Rating removal. While J2O does allow you to give ratings significantly different from the average, the policy requires that you support your position in somewhat more detail than is required for an average review, as you have more to prove than simply “I agree with everyone else”. In any case, your points basically amount to “this tileset is brown” and “I’m not sure how to use it”, the latter of which is weird because the tileset is mostly large blocks without much assembly required… meanwhile, basing ratings on example levels is forbidden. ~Violet)

RecommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
10 Jun 2006, 07:33 (edited 10 Jun 06, 07:33)
For: Saphir's First Racepack
Level rating: 8.1
Rating
10

Saphir’s First Racepack:

Rating:
This good racepack is good. And not a little bit, but very!
Each round can take a very long time, because the levels are all very big.

Peter and myself played a tournament and the one that has average the shortest time wins.
The loser are doing the dishes. Peter was the loser, with an average time of 16:27:83. I won with 13:52:11.

It has lots of differents circuits: in space, in a lab, in a pinball-machine, in caves… Saphir: how much time did you spend on this great episode?

With other words: your first levelpack is a great pack for a whole tournament. Well done!

The eyecandy and gameplay are super!

Conclusion:
Saphir’s First Racepack doesn’t earn a 7,6, but a fat 10. If you want to do a race-tournament with your friends, this pack is THE racepack that you need. For everyone is at least one good level and this is absolute a download recommendation.

Mark: 10,0
Download recommendation: YES

RecommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
10 Jun 2006, 07:14
For: Muckamok (remake)
Level rating: 8.5
Rating
8.5

Rating Remake Muckamok

Rating:
This is a disappointment. Normally is Gus a great tileset-creator. Sorry Gus, but this is a 1.

Hahaha! I’m joking, Gus. Yes, I like jokes and I want to be a clown.

But now serious: this remake from the classical Muckamok-tileset is extremely good. Good colors. Lots of green of course. There are lots of slimey mountains, green mud etc. And in the example-level you can discover how I must use the tileset.

Conclusion:
For everyone that like the tilesets from Gus and like remakes from JJ1-tilesets it is sure a download recommendation. So, this tileset is really no disappointment. On the contrary: it is one of the best JJ1-remakes I’ve ever seen!

Mark:
Download recommendation: YES!

RecommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
10 Jun 2006, 06:41 (edited 10 Jun 06, 07:36)
For: Ocean of Acid
Level rating: 8.4
Rating
8.8

Rating Ocean of Acid

Rating:
Ocean of Acid is one, gigantic Single Player-level. It is extremely hard, but not inpossible. I was able to complete it with all three characters. (also Lori!) That’s a plus.

It is manifest why this level is called ‘Ocean of Acid’. If you fall, you’ll fall in a ocean of acid.
If you fall in the ocean of acid, you need to return to a platform immediately, before you die.

The eyecandy is good. There are also lots of obstacles, like the acid. There are many enemies, good placed in this large level. This Jazz2 Fan has made a good job.

But there is no boss. And if there is a Single Player-episode I always hope on one or more bosses. But also without boss this level is still very great!

Conclusion:
Despite the fact that there is no boss, this is still an excellent level.

Mark: 8,8
Download recommendation: YES!

RecommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
7 Jun 2006, 18:20
For: Familiar World
Level rating: 7.5
Rating
8.9

Rating Familiar World

Rating Story: (X1)
It is a good story!
Rating:

Rating Length: (X2)
Three pretty large playable levels (the last is the ending) filled with lots of puzzles. Good!
Rating: 9

Rating Gameplay: (X2)
In the three levels are lots of puzzles, obstacles and bosses at the end of each level. That are the best levels!
Rating:

Rating Obstacles: (X2)
With the enemies, bosses, fire, lava and life-risking puzzles the levels are very hard! But there are some bugs…
Rating: 8

Rating Bonusses: (X1)
The goodies and crystals are good placed!
Rating:

Rating Eyecandy: (X2)
The foreground is good! The background is good and you have created beautiful paths!
Rating: 9

Final Rating: 8,9
Download recommendation: YES!

Not recommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
6 Jun 2006, 17:18
For: Toby episode
Level rating: 5.1
Rating
2.1

Rating Toby Episode:

Rating Obstacles: (X2)
So-so. The spikes are good placed. The enemies are also not very bad, but the boss-placement is abomiable. However, the first of the two bosses is OK, but the final boss…? (Toby) It is much too hard to beat him and the level doesn’t end automatically after you’ve beated him. A better selfmade final boss is the Spike Machine, created by Gus in the episode ‘Flashback: Outta dis world’.
Rating:

Rating Bonus Placement: (X1)
In the level ‘Dark’ is it very bad. At the begin is it OK, but then are there no bonusses at all. The rest is all OK.
Rating:

Rating Story: (X1)
No story.
Rating N/A

Rating Eyecandy: (X2)
Too cruel. There is much too much blood to score any higher than the lowest mark as possible.´
Rating: 1

Rating Length: (X2)
Ten levels and one credits. That is OK, but the levels are too short for a sufficient.
Rating: 5

Final Rating: 2,1
Download recommendation: NO!

Review by Ischa

Posted:
4 Jun 2006, 06:01 (edited 4 Jun 06, 06:02)
For: Redwarprace(prototype)
Level rating: 1
Rating
N/A

Worse!

Review by Ischa

Posted:
3 Jun 2006, 18:47
For: The water castle
Level rating: N/A
Rating
N/A

Good level! It is a pity that I can’t give it a mark… if marks also were allowed I’m sure that I’ll give you a high mark, at least a big fat 7.

Greetings,
Ischa

Review by Ischa

Posted:
29 May 2006, 17:00 (edited 30 May 06, 12:55)
For: Shadow of the Past: Demo edition
Level rating: 5
Rating
5.8

RATING SHADOW OF PAST

Rating Eyecandy: (max: 15 points)
Foreground: is good created! (12)
Path: Path: there are lots of beautiful paths (12)
Background: also good! (12)
12+12+12/3=12 (duh)
Points: 12

Rating Difficulty: (max 15 points)
This level is much too hard. Sorry, but I can’t give you more than 5 points.
Points: 5

Rating Bonusses: (max 10 points)
At the beginning is a square filled with food. That is a pity. For the rest is this placement OK.
Points: 6

Rating Story: (max 10 points)
There is no story. This rating doesn’t count for your endmark.
Points: N/A

Rating Length: (max 15 points)
It is one level, but it is pretty long.
Points: 9

NUMBER OF POINTS: 32
MAX POINTS: 65-10(story)=*55*
CALCULATING: 32/5.5 = 5.5,8181818181818181818181818181818*

Final Rating: 5,8
Download Recommendation: N/AO! (Yes requires 7,5)

Review by Ischa

Posted:
27 May 2006, 11:04
For: Love is in the Hare
Level rating: 5.7
Rating
6.5

REVIEW LOVE IS IN THE HARE

Rating Eyecandy: max: 15 points
Foreground: is good! (12)
Path: there are lots of beautiful paths (12)
Background: good, but it moves too fast (9)
12+12+9/3=11
Points: 11

Rating Enemies: max: 15 points
You have placed the enemies very, very good! The only pity is this: no boss.
Points: 12

Rating Bonusses: max: 10 points
All bonusses for a good Single-Player-level are placed, but it are much too much bonusses. Sorry, friend.
Points: 4

Rating Story: max: 10 points
There is no story!
This review doesn’t count for your endmark!
Points: N/A

Rating Length: max: 15 points
It is one level, but it is pretty long.
Points: 9

MAXIMAL NUMBER OF POINTS: 65-10(story)=*55*
POINTS EARNED: 36
CALCULATING: 36/5,5=*6,5454545454545454545454545454545*

Final Rating: 6,5
Download Recommendation: N/A (requires 7,5)

Good luck with your next episode!

All the best,
Ischa

Not recommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
26 May 2006, 14:17 (edited 29 May 06, 17:09)
For: 120 Minutes in Heaven
Level rating: 7.3
Rating
5.3

Rating Frogger Levels

Rating Story: (max: 10 points)
No story!
Points: N/A (DOESN’T COUNT IN FINAL RATING)

Rating Length: (max: 20 points)
Just one level… and it is also not very long.
Points: 6

Rating Obstacles: (max: 20 points)
The level is not very hard… that is a pity.
Points: 8

Rating Bonus Placement: (max: 15 points)
Is good! Very good! Not too much, not too less bonusses.
Points: 13

Rating Eyecandy: (max: 15 points)
Foreground: So-so: 8
Background: Good: 12
Path: Not bad: 10
8+12+10/3=10
Points: 10

NUMBER OF POINTS: 37
MAX POINTS: 80-10(story)=*70*
CALCULATING: 37/7=5,2857142857142857142857142857143

Final Rating: 5,3
Download recommendation: NO!
N/A requires 5,5
Yes requires 7,5

RecommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
20 May 2006, 17:18
For: Devan\'s Secret Weapon
Level rating: 8.2
Rating
8.4

Rating Devan’s Secret Weapon

Rating Story: (X1)
There is a story, but it is not very clear.
Rating: N/A

Rating Obstacles: (X2)
Both levels are very, very hard! Lots of puzzles, enemies and traps!
Rating: 9,1

Rating Bonus Placement: (X1)
The bonusses are good placed. Not too much and also not too less.
Rating: 8,8

Rating Length: (X2)
Just two levels, but level one is very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very long. And level 2 has a normal length.
Rating: 6,7

Rating Gameplay: (X2)
The gameplay for both levels are very good! The best are the routes that you need to complete to open the next part of the level.
Rating: 9,2

Final Rating: 8,4
Download recommendation: YES!

Review by Ischa

Posted:
20 May 2006, 06:06 (edited 20 May 06, 06:07)
For: Diamond Factory
Level rating: 6.9
Rating
6.6

Rating Diamond Factory:

Rating Enemies: (X2)
Is not bad, but it could even better.
Rating: 6,5

Rating Bonusses: (X1)
There are a good number of bonusses and secrets, but some are too easy too find. And in the final level you can get lots of diamonds under the second pipe of the machine.
Rating: 6

Rating Story: (X1)
First I thought this game has no story, but at the begin of the game Eva has told it. But please, put next time the story in the Level Description.
Rating: 7,1

Rating Gameplay: (X2)
It could even better, but this is not bad.
Rating: 6,9

Rating Length: (X2)
Four levels and 1 credit-level… that is not bad. But if you want a better rating, create more levels in the next episode.
Rating: 6,6

Final Rating: 6,6
Download Recommendation: N/A (requires a 7,5)

Not recommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
16 May 2006, 16:58 (edited 16 May 06, 16:59)
For: What rabbit swiming fastest?
Level rating: 1.2
Rating
1

Rating Which rabbit swiming fastest?

Difficulty: (X2)
It is the easiest race-level I know!
Rating: 1,0

Design: (X2)
Horrible! No backgroud, no foreground and no bottom!
Rating: 1,0

Orgineel: (X1)
Not good! It is not orginal, because there are more straight race-levels. It is just under water, that’s all.
Rating: 1,0

Eindcijfer: 1,0
Downloadaanrader: NO!

RecommendedReview by Ischa

Posted:
14 May 2006, 06:54 (edited 14 May 06, 06:58)
For: Miracle of Sun
Level rating: 9.5
Rating
7.9

Rating Miracle of Sun

A tileset with a gigantic Single Player-level in it.

Rating Practical: (X2)
It is not the most practical tileset, because it is very, very big.
But you can create lots of back/foregrounds and different types of path.
Rating: 6,1

Rating Beauty: (X2)
It is a beautiful tileset. I have nothing more too say. But most of the tileset is red and that’s a pity.
Rating: 8-

Rating Orginality: (X1)
Good! Very original. You have created lots of differents things, like a disco, a restaurant, a beach etc.
Rating: 10+

Rating Example Level: (X1)
You have created a good example level. It is more a Single-Player-level! That is very good if you want to see how I need to use your tileset! But there is one bug: if you press ESC and select OPTIONS, the server will crash.
Rating: 8,7

Final Rating: 7,9
Download Recommendation: YES!

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7